Home
Articles
Reform in Patent Legislation

“Change starts when someone sees the next step.”
William Drayton

Developed countries are adamant about extending the reach of patent laws for protection of intellectual rights in concluding bilateral and multilateral trade agreements.

Patent legislation is a government intervention for correction of a market failure. New knowledge creation requires high investments; but, once it is created it can easily be duplicated, benefiting a large number of people without contributing to the necessary investments, and thereby not allowing a reasonable return to the original investor. Unless those who make such investments earn an adequate return, society as a whole will not be allocating sufficient resources for innovations. Patent laws aim to grant, for a definite period, a monopoly right to those who are successful in their investment. The purpose is to ensure an adequate level of investment in innovation and creativity, before allowing information to freely circulate following the expiry of the identified period. Indeed, countries where effective patent laws are in force enjoy more encouragement for creativity and greater number of inventions.

However, government intervention in this area, as is the case of many other areas, lags behind the market conditions. We should question whether it is appropriate to keep the provision allowing for a 20-year patent protection, adopted by taking a specific country as the relevant market, to remain the same when patent protection is simultaneously granted in more than one country. In an environment where the period needed for an invention to be developed into a readily marketable product with a short payback period, and at a time when capital markets reward innovations even before they bring a single penny, should the period of monopoly right remain the same?

Another point to question in connection with patent legislation is the type of innovations that deserve to be included in the patent scope as far as public interest is concerned. For example the US Compton New Media had obtained patent for combining sound, vision and writing in a multimedia disc in 1993. The fact that patent was granted to the first applicant for a technology already in use at that date by many companies in their in-house applications gave rise to doubts as to whether Patent Office had the necessary resources for evaluating innovations for patent issuing purposes. In fact, the US Patent Office had to review its decision in this respect. Nowadays Patent Office is under pressure for launching a study in connection with the optimal duration for internet patents.

The duration, which is longer than necessary, of the monopoly rights under the patent legislation may prove to be a factor restricting development. It may also delay global development due to excessive resource transfers from countries with limited capital accumulation to those enjoying greater number of patents.

It is true that global regulatory measures are needed for the protection of intellectual rights; however the parameters for such regulatory measures should be reviewed in line with the changing conditions of the present day. We are not questioning the need for patent rights, but the parameters that would serve the global society in the most equitable and efficient way. In correcting a market failure, we should be careful not to suppress the global society’s development potential.

Dr. Argüden
yarguden@arge.com


Ethical Leadership for the Future
People focus more on corporate actions after the ethics scandals at the end of 20th and...
From Global Crisis to Global Governance
The mortgage crises that started in the US in 2008 soon turned into a global crisis....
Responsible Boards – Action Plan for a Sustainable Future
A sustainable global economy is one that combines long-term profitability with ethical behavior, social justice, and...
Right Reward for Right Performance
Aligning Executive Compensation with Good Governance Dr. Yılmaz Argüden1 “Price is what you pay. Value is...
Is More Regulation the Right Recipe for Better Governance
Increasing regulation of corporate governance is becoming a new trend in many jurisdictions. Yet good governance...
Rio+20 was a Bust
World leaders from government, the business world, NGOs and academia gathered at the UN’s Rio+20 summit....
Why Boards Need More Women
Diversity on boards is critical to sustaining performance. Broadening the composition of the board increases the...
Global Boards Help Make Companies Global
For organizations to endure, they must strike a balance between risks and rewards, short-term objectives and...
Attitude is everything: The case for Turkiye
Recent local elections have been a wake up call for numerous European leaders such as Angela...
Diversity at the Head Table
PDF olarak indirmek için tıklayın.
Measuring the effectiveness of corporate governance
Trust is the foundation of sustainable development. As the world continues to get smaller, our mutual...
ARGE Corporate Governance Model©
PDF olarak indirmek için tıklayın.
Consensual Delegation of Sovereignty
Thanks to changes in IMF voting, countries such as China, Mexico, and Türkiye now have a...
The Power of Inclusion
Editor’s note: When US President Barack Obama landed in Ankara on Monday, April 6, 2009, it...
From Global Crises to Global Governance
In a perspective from Turkiye, top business strategist and civic leader Yilmaz Argüden explores how global...
Opportunity from Crisis: Obama’s Chance for Real Global Leadership
In a perspective from Turkiye, top business strategist and civic leader Yilmaz Argüden argues that Barack...
Europe’s Dilemma: Values vs Interests and Protectionism vs Leadership
For decades European development has been guided by a number of key values: human rights, democracy,...
Digital Transformation and the Board’s Role
Digital players are threatening the traditional sectors and their business models and most of the executives...
Board And Innovation
Innovation is one of the most important issues in global business environment, nowadays. Innovation involves creation...
Legislating History
Recently various Parliaments throughout the world started to get in the business of legislating history!! Generally...
US – Turkish Cooperation Based on Shared Values
Since 9/11, the US unilateralism has been widely interpreted as a projection of hard power to...
Shaping The Future
The choices we make today shape not only the current results, but also the future. However,...
Water and Global Governance
The 5th World Water Forum has convened in Istanbul. Water is life. Everywhere and every day we need it. Water...
The Missing Political Debate
The US presidential elections have profound implications not just for the US, but also for the...
Lead Indicators
Managers usually make their decisions based on metrics, which can easily be measured and has an...
Family Businesses
Happy families are all alike, but each unhappy family has reasons of its own. Leo Tolstoy...
European Union and Turkiye in 2020
“The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams.” Eleanor Roosevelt Let...
Civil Society in Support of University
“Only the educated are free” Epictetus That the importance of education increases further everyday is beyond...
Democratization of Capital
“You cannot escape the responsibility of tomorrow by escaping today.” Abraham Lincoln In today’s world only...
Second Career
“Life consists not in holding good cards but in playing those you hold well.” Joel Billings...
Center of Attraction
“It is not in the stars to hold our destiny, but in ourselves.” William Shakespeare To...
Going Beyond the Borders
“The shell must break before the bird can fly.” Lord Alfred Tennyson The greatest obstacle to...
Galatasaray and Education of a Nation
“Winning is not everything, but the will to win is everthing.” Vince Lombardi Education of a...
Corporate Governance
“The best way to create trust in an organization is to open all doors – from...
Those Who Fail to Share, Will Be Shared Out
“Dünyada görmek istediğin değişimi, önce kendinde gerçekleştirmelisin.” Mahatma Gandhi Unprecedent improvements in information and communication technologies,...
Representative Democracy to Participatory Democracy
“A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.” Confucius Decisions that are not...
Reform in Patent Legislation
“Change starts when someone sees the next step.” William Drayton Developed countries are adamant about extending...
Leaders Magazine Interview
LEADERS Magazine Interview Questions for: Dr. Yılmaz Argüden Chairman ARGE Consulting, Istanbul Senior Advisor and Representative...
Managing Diversity
Ladies and Gentlemen, It is a great pleasure and honor for me to address you to...
World Leadership by Example: Challenge for EU
The potential of EU for the leadership of the world was the subject of the largest...
Education for Sustainable Global Governance
Vision: The world will be a more stable and innovative place to live for the human...
Global Fault Line
Humanity’s search for truth and curiosity to reach further locations have been an ever lasting ambition....
Turkish-American relations and TAİK
Turkish-U.S. Business Council (TAİK) Chairman Dr. Yılmaz Argüden answered our questions concerning Turkish-American relations and the...
Global NATO
The most important role of government is to provide security and maintain stability. Significant changes occurred...